GameFAQs is supremely lol, and it always has been, so I wouldn't even bother even if I had vidding abilities. I empathize, though. I personally don't find as many flaws in Sonic games as these people do, unless I'm actually trying, in which case I've already gone through tons of it, and I'd love for them to see how playable I feel Neo-Sonic games are. However, despite this, you just can't change someone's opinion like that. These people are dead-set on retrogaming and SA2B obsession, and knowing them after having a minor argument with one of these people once, you will NOT like what their responses will be, and some may in fact be true (although usually only to a certain degree). For example, they might say something like "oh, you had to go through several restarts". It's worthless arguing with them, because not only will they get pissed and look like an ass to people like us and Neo-Sonic fans, but you'll look like an ass too.
In short, this is like blowing out a large fire. You think it's possible to kill it slowly in parts, but in fact it does nothing, brings you near the fire, and is a dumb idea. Sorry, thorn, but that's just the way it is.